Trump Supporters Reveal their Hypocrisy on Political Correctness

Last Friday, a candidate for the presidency of the United States said something that was not politically correct. That candidate's opponents loudly demanded an apology, claiming those remarks were offensive. The chairman of the opposing party released a statement saying the remarks showed "contempt for ordinary people." The highest-ranking elected official from that chairman's same party tweeted that this candidate "should be ashamed" of the remarks.

The candidate was Hillary Clinton, who glibly said that half of Donald Trump's supporters fall into a "basket of deplorables - The racist, sexist, homophobic, xenophobic, Islamaphobic." She eventually walked back those remarks, admitting that it was inappropriate to generalize so many of Trump's supporters in this way. Nonetheless, she reiterated that Trump had built his campaign "largely on prejudice and paranoia." 

Amidst such a crazy campaign, this controversy is almost refreshingly familiar. One candidate says something hyperbolic, inelegant, or ill-advised and the opposing side responds with outrage. Ultimately, someone issues an apology and we all move on. This all has echoes of President Barack Obama's "guns and religion" gaffe, or Mitt Romney's claim that "47 percent" of Americans were dependent on the government.

The issue is that Donald Trump makes these kinds of remarks on an almost weekly basis. He began his campaign with a racist rant against Mexican immigrants. He's insulted women, Gold Star familiespeople of color, and the disabled. One of his signature policy proposals is to ban an entire religion from entering the United States. He's written off Vladimir Putin's murdering of journalists and has developed a cozy relationship with white supremacists. Trump adopts a blanket excuse for why we should not care about these statements: he doesn't "have time to be politically correct." He's argued that "political correctness is killing us," and he therefore refuses to express remorse for any of the outrageous things he has said. 

Somehow, the very same Republican Party officials who lashed out in outrage at Hillary Clinton's "deplorables" remark were not offended by their candidate's repeated displays of prejudice against large swaths of the American public. I agree that Hillary Clinton should have expressed regret for her remarks, but it is patently hypocritical for the Republican Party and its leaders not to hold their nominee to that same standard. 

Amanda Taub wrote earlier this year that "'politically correct' is a term we use to dismiss ideas that make us uncomfortable." This controversy has proven that to be true. Trump and his supporters are uncomfortable hearing that they hold racist views, and excuse such criticisms as rampant political correctness. Unsurprisingly, they do not feel the same way about hyperbolic and mean-spirited statements thrown in their direction.

The reality is that "political correctness" is a term invented by the privileged to justify insults against less privileged individuals. By speaking out against the "racist, sexist, homophobic, xenophobic, Islamaphobic" elements of Trump's campaign, Clinton used inelegant and undiplomatic language in defense of several under-privileged groups. Therefore, her remarks cannot be excused by political correctness. Unfortunately, those on the receiving end of Clinton's remarks will continue to enjoy the benefits of their privilege for this reason.

While Clinton may have misrepresented the degree of Trump's racist support, it is there nonetheless for all to see. If there was ever an issue in this election worthy of employing inelegant language to appropriately confront the threat, the bigotry Trump has unleashed is it. I can only hope that after November 8, serious Republican leaders recognize their partisan-driven hypocrisy and begin again the work of reclaiming their party from the "deplorables." 

The Positive Case for Hillary Clinton

In April of last year, Hillary Clinton finally confirmed one of the country's worst kept secrets when she announced that she would run to succeed Barack Obama as President. For a brief few weeks, Clinton was at the center of political media coverage from outlets left, right, and center as she consistently led in pre-primary polls. The smart money in Washington assumed that the 2016 election would play out as a referendum on Barack Obama's presidency and a test of American voters' appetite for Hillary Clinton's leadership. The Republican Party, and particularly the Republican National Committee (RNC), saw Clinton's nomination as inevitable and spent the early months of the pre-primary season laying the groundwork for their party's case against her. This all seems like an eternity ago. 

We all know what happened next: The Republican Party became engulfed in a long, bitter primary fight that diverted attention and resources away from their eventual opponent and elevated an awful demagogue in Donald Trump to the nomination. Although Trump repeatedly made headlines with his racist announcement speech, xenophobic policy proposals, and crude debate jabs, the media treated him largely as an entertaining side show for months. On the Democratic side, Bernie Sanders built a more formidable challenge than anyone expected, but fell well short of the nomination nonetheless. 

The media narrative has since shifted in a big way as the reality of Trump's nomination has sunk in. While Trump and his campaign have done themselves no favors, it is disingenuous to claim that the Republican nominee is "imploding." He's simply doing what he's always done. Our reaction as a nation is what has changed, not the candidate. Nonetheless, fear of a Trump presidency lingers over the country like a hurricane forming offshore and his campaign continues to dominate media coverage, for better or worse. 

What has gotten lost in the shuffle is the fact that there is another candidate in this race.  Once the darling of the 2016 narrative, Hillary Clinton has since succumbed to the media's obsession with scandal (both real and imagined) and her opponent. I am extremely skeptical that there is much that Clinton can do through traditional media to reclaim the narrative or to make a positive case for her candidacy without getting brought down to Trump's level. The general election debates (if they happen) may be an opportunity to do just that, but in the meantime, it's up to her supporters to make the case. Here are just a few reasons why Hillary Clinton will make an excellent President:

1. Hillary Clinton is one of the most qualified nominees in modern history

Hillary Clinton is objectively one of the most well-credentialed individuals ever to appear on a presidential ballot. Her resume is her greatest strength. She has been an enormously successful lawyer, the nation's most proactive First Lady, a senator, and Secretary of State. Lest you think that Hillary Clinton's notoriety depends on that of her husband, don't forget that she made national headlines in 1969 by calling out Senator Edward Brooke (R-MA) on stage at her own college graduation. When Hillary and Bill met on the campus of Yale Law a few years later, Hillary was the better-known of the two. 

Most importantly, Hillary Clinton has been universally praised by her colleagues throughout her career as a dedicated and prepared leader. Many of the same Republican Members of Congress who attack her service now were actually quite complimentary of Clinton while she served both in the Senate and as Secretary of State. Despite what you hear on television, their criticisms are political, not personal or professional. 

2. Hillary Clinton has a strong record of achieving progressive change

Unlike many of her classmates, when Hillary Clinton graduated from Yale Law, she did not cash in on a cushy job at a high-powered firm. (Even President Obama worked in the private sector before taking up community organizing full-time.) Instead, she went to work for the Children's Defense Fund to fight for civil rights and economic justice in places like New Bedford, Massachusetts, which coincidentally is close to where I grew up. Hillary Clinton found disabled immigrant children, whose schools had cast them aside, and made sure that they got an education. 

Hillary Clinton would then go on to work on Capitol Hill, where she helped build the case for Richard Nixon's impeachment. After moving to Arkansas and marrying Bill, Hillary would co-found Arkansas Advocates for Children and Families, demonstrating that she had not left her passion for protecting children's rights behind. While President, Jimmy Carter appointed Hillary to the board of the Legal Services Corporation (LSC), which provides legal aid to those who cannot otherwise afford it. She would eventually serve as the LSC's first female Chair. All of these accomplishments pre-date Bill Clinton's election as Governor of Arkansas.

I won't belabor the point by listing her many accomplishments, except to say that Hillary Clinton as Senator and Secretary of State was never the moderate her husband was. She opposed both of President George W. Bush's tax cuts in the Senate, along with the Supreme Court nominations of Justice Alito and Chief Justice Roberts. While Secretary of State, she championed a variety of progressive issues around the globe, especially women's rights and equality for the LGBT community. Within the State Department itself, Hillary Clinton instituted several human resources reforms aimed at helping her same-sex employees. 

In short, Hillary Clinton gets things done, and those things almost always support the furtherance of progressive priorities. 

3. Hillary Clinton has a positive vision for America

A photo posted by Nicholas Blake (@ncblake) on

I dare you to watch Hillary Clinton's announcement video, which I included at the beginning of this post. Now, watch Donald Trump's announcement speech. The same experiment will work if you substitute the above with the nominees' respective convention speeches.

It is abundantly clear that Hillary Clinton is the only candidate left in the race with a positive vision for America. By contrast, Donald Trump never misses an opportunity to let us know how awful things are in this country, despite all evidence to the contrary. The economy has rebounded from a historic financial crisis, crime is at historic lows, and President Obama has a positive approval rating after all that's been thrown at him. Unfortunately, when the facts are not on Trump's side, he has a tendency to ignore them and paint a competing narrative based on pure fiction. We must reject such nonsense. 

It should go without saying, but we are a better country than the one in which Donald Trump believes he lives. Americans have always rejected racism, bigotry, xenophobia, and demagoguery in the long run and must do so again. Hillary Clinton recognizes and will celebrate that our diversity makes America (already) great, and will work to make our country even greater. Even better, she comes prepared with a plan to do just that from day one.

A photo posted by Nicholas Blake (@ncblake) on

The stakes in this election could not be higher, but it is not enough to despise Donald Trump. We must also hit the pavement and the phones for Hillary Clinton. If you aren't sure how to get started, get in touch with the campaign and they'll give you the tools.